Steve and Lisa were first home buyers looking for something increasingly difficult to find in Melbourne: a house with land in the Eltham area. During the search, we identified a property that looked like a strong fit.
It ticked many of the boxes we had been looking for, it was going to auction, and based on what we knew at the time, we were preparing to bid. But before we got anywhere near auction day, there was an important step we wanted Steve and Lisa to take. We recommended a combined building and pest inspection.
“Do We Really Need to Spend $700?”
Like many first home buyers, Steve and Lisa were conscious of every dollar they were spending. A combined building and pest inspection was going to cost approximately $700, and understandably, they questioned whether it was really necessary.
They were comfortable accepting a little more risk. From their perspective, the property looked good, they liked it, and they were prepared to go to auction without the additional expense. We weren't as comfortable.
Our experience in the Eltham area meant we were particularly conscious of the potential for termite activity. With the type of property and the location, we believed that spending the money to properly investigate the home before making an unconditional purchase at auction was worthwhile. So we pushed back.
Not because we knew there was a problem. We didn't. But because good due diligence isn't about investigating only when you already know something is wrong. It's about identifying the things you don't know before they become your problem.
Good due diligence isn't about investigating only when you know something is wrong. It's about identifying what you don't know before it becomes your problem.
Steve and Lisa took our advice and commissioned the inspection. It turned out to be one of the most valuable $700 they could have spent.
The Inspection Changed Everything
The building and pest inspection identified evidence of a significant termite infestation. More concerningly, the problem wasn't isolated to a small area that could simply be treated and forgotten. An entire side of the house had suffered structural damage associated with the termite infestation.
Suddenly, we were looking at a very different property. What had appeared to be a home worth bidding on at auction now carried a potentially substantial structural issue, with the possibility of significant repair costs and further investigation required.
For Steve and Lisa, particularly as first home buyers, it fundamentally changed the risk associated with the purchase. Our recommendation was clear. We weren't buying this property.
Our recommendation was simple: we're not buying this property.
Steve and Lisa withdrew and we moved on with the search.
But the Property Still Sold
The property proceeded to auction. And somebody bought it. That part of the story is important. A property selling successfully doesn't necessarily mean there was nothing wrong with it.
A busy auction, competitive bidding or another buyer's willingness to purchase doesn't replace independent due diligence. We knew what our inspection had uncovered. And Steve and Lisa were able to make their decision with that information in front of them.
Instead of potentially becoming the owners of a home with significant termite-related structural damage, they walked away having spent approximately $700 to uncover a problem that could have cost them vastly more after settlement.
How the decision unfolded
- 1The searchProperty identifiedA house with land in the Eltham area, going to auction.
- 2Before auctionWe recommend a building and pest inspectionBased on our experience in Eltham and the type of property.
- 3The hesitation“Do we really need to spend $700?”Steve and Lisa were conscious of every dollar as first home buyers.
- 4The inspectionSignificant termite damage discoveredStructural damage across an entire side of the house.
- 5The decisionWe weren’t buying this propertySteve and Lisa withdrew and the search moved on.
- 6Auction dayThe property sellsOther buyers proceeded. Our clients had the information in front of them.
Sometimes Success Means Not Buying
It's easy to measure the success of a Buyer's Advocate by the properties we purchase. How quickly did we find it? How much did we negotiate off the price? Did we win the auction?
But that's only part of our job. Sometimes the most important advice we can give a client is: Don't buy this property. Our responsibility isn't to get a deal done at any cost. It's to help our clients make informed property decisions and understand the risks before they commit hundreds of thousands, or potentially millions, of dollars.
That is particularly important at auction. In Victoria, residential properties purchased at auction are generally sold on an unconditional basis, so buyers need to understand what they're purchasing before they bid.
For Steve and Lisa, spending approximately $700 on due diligence prevented them from taking on a property with significant termite-related structural damage. They didn't walk away from auction day with a house. They walked away from a potentially very expensive mistake.
And we'd consider that a successful outcome every time.
Sometimes the most valuable property advice is knowing when to walk away.
